Alaska Rep. Don Young suggests Jews with guns could have stopped Nazis – By Jonathan Allen and Alex Moe (nbcnews.com) / Feb 28 2018
WASHINGTON — Jewish people would have been able to fend off the Nazis if not for gun-control laws imposed by the Third Reich, Rep. Don Young, a Republican from Alaska, argued last week.
“How many millions were shot and killed because they were unarmed?” Young asked at an event in Juneau, Alaska, before answering his own question. “Fifty million in Russia because their citizens were unarmed. How many Jews were put into the ovens because they were unarmed?”
Young’s words, offered in response to a question about guns in the wake of the Parkland, Fla., high school shootings earlier this month, drew criticism from the Anti-Defamation League, a national organization that aims to counter anti-Semitism.
“Guns, or lack of them, did not cause the Holocaust,” the ADL wrote on Twitter. “The Holocaust was the product of anti-Semitism & other forms of hate. It’s offensive for anyone to manipulate the history of the Holocaust to score political points.”
Rep. Nita Lowey, D-N.Y., who is Jewish, condemned Young’s remarks Wednesday.
.@repdonyoung’s comment was disgusting & reprehensible, not to mention one of the dumbest things I have ever heard. https://t.co/dM1HaAVhiH
— Archive: Nita Lowey (@NitaLowey) February 28, 2018
Young spokesperson Murphy McCollough said the congressman’s comments had been “taken entirely out of context.”
“He was referencing the fact that when Hitler confiscated firearms from Jewish Germans, those communities were less able to defend themselves,” McCollough said. “He was not implying that an armed Jewish population would have been able to prevent the horrors of the Holocaust, but his intended message is that disarming citizens can have detrimental consequences.”
Young, who is the longest-serving member of the House, isn’t the first politician to float this Holocaust hypothesis, nor is it the first time the 84-year-old has gotten himself in hot water with commentary that roiled a minority group.
Housing and Urban Development Secretary Ben Carson made the same assertion, which has been embraced by conservative gun defenders for years, on the presidential campaign trail in 2015.
“I think the likelihood of Hitler being able to accomplish his goals would have been greatly diminished if the people had been armed,” Carson said in an interview. “I’m telling you there is a reason these dictatorial people take guns first.”
PolitiFact, fact checking Carson’s statement at the time, rated the claim that gun control laws enabled Nazis to carry out the Holocaust “false.”
The House Natural Resources Committee, of which Young is chairman emeritus, also caused a small stir last year when it invited Stephen Halbrook, author of “Gun Control in the Third Reich,” to testify on legislation that would eliminate a $200-per-unit tax on silencers to one equal to 10 percent of the value of the device, and loosen restrictions on transporting hunting and fishing equipment on federal lands.
In 2013, Young was forced to apologize after he referred to migrant workers as “wetbacks” in a radio interview.
Then-House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, called Young’s comment “beneath the dignity of the office he holds.”
Young, elected in 1972, became the “dean of the House” — the chamber’s longest-serving member — in December, after the resignation of John Conyers, D-Mich.
He was congratulated on the House floor by Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis., and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., in January when lawmakers paused legislative business to honor his accomplishment.
The video of Young’s comments was released by Dimitri Shein, who identifies himself as Young’s Democratic congressional opponent.
PB/TK – we can argue fact and fiction all day yet in 1933 there was roughly 505,000 German Jews among the 60+ million German population. The odds were not in the German Jews favor and let’s not forget the American Pre-1940 was a “stay the path” and didn’t relax on immigration laws due to the Great Depression.
